British Columbia

Over 50 years after their communities were displaced, 2 residents from Hogan's Alley and Africville connect

Irvine Carvery, who is from Africville in Halifax, and Randy Clark, from Hogan's Alley in Vancouver, connect over their communities' similar pasts — and a shared vision for the future of Black Canadians.

Irvine Carvery and Randy Clark did a walking tour of what remains of Hogan's Alley in Vancouver

Two men are smiling while posing for the camera. They're both holding up gifts that they exchanged with each other.
Randy Clark grew up in Hogan's Alley, in Vancouver. Irvine Carvery grew up in Africville, in Nova Scotia. They met for the first time earlier this month. (Gurpreet Kambo/CBC News)

Hogan's Alley in Vancouver and Africville in Halifax have a special connection, says Irvine Carvery, a former resident of the Black neighbourhood in Nova Scotia.

"Both of our communities were victims of urban renewal," he said.

On opposite sides of the country, Hogan's Alley and Africville were hubs for Black Canadian culture and life. 

But residents of both neighbourhoods were also displaced by construction, causing ruptures in the lives of many Black Canadians.

During a planned walking tour of what remains of Hogan's Alley on Aug. 11, Carvery met Randy Clark, a former resident of the Vancouver neighbourhood.

The men felt an instant connection.

"Not only is there a kinship ... the playbook that was used by those in power, those in charge ... was very, very similar," Clark said of their communities' displacement.

Making people 'totally dependent upon the system'

Carvery was born in Africville, and learned of its history from his grandfather, who also grew up there.

"You won't find the Carvery name attached to any other community, other than in Africa," he said.

The town was home to a community of African Nova Scotians for over a century.  

A yellow church replica sits in a park overlooking the harbour.
A replica of the Africville church was built following an apology and settlement by the Halifax Regional Municipality. Africville was razed gradually by the city between 1964-67. (Michael Gorman/CBC)

"We depended on each other to make it through the hard times," said Carvery. "It was really, truly [a] community." 

Africville was razed gradually by the City of Halifax between 1964-67. Carvery was 13 years old when he and his family were relocated.

"With the move, they destroyed that community," said Carvery, adding that people were moved to public housing, and many soon had to rely on welfare support.

"They took an independent people and made them totally dependent upon the system."

According to Carvery, the move destroyed not only the physical assets of Africville, but also the culture and heritage of those who had called it home. 

WATCH | A history of Africville:

A walk through the Africville Museum

2 years ago
Duration 6:46
It's been just over a week since the National Black Canadians Summit wrapped up in Halifax. During the event, delegates visited locations to explore the 400-year-long history of Black Canadians in Nova Scotia. One of those sites was the Africville Museum, which tells the story of a vibrant community torn apart and razed by the city in the 1960s.

'We've lost a lot over the generations'

For Clark, Carvery's experiences of Africville on the east coast mirrored his own on the west.

Clark's grandparents owned Vie's Chicken and Steak House, a popular restaurant in Hogan's Alley that attracted many Black celebrities as guests. Clark lived across the street with his family.

A photo of Hogan's Alley
Hogan’s Alley, the historic location where many of B.C’s first Black immigrants settled in the early 1900s, is pictured in Vancouver in August 2020. It was razed in 1967 to make way for the Georgia Street Viaduct. (Maggie MacPherson/CBC)

The area was established as a Black neighbourhood in the 1850s. Like Africville, it was a hub for the local Black community for over 100 years.

It was razed in 1967 to make way for the Georgia Street Viaduct. 

"[The viaduct] ran right through the block, and three blocks on either side," he said."That's why people had to make the decision to leave.

Clark says he recalls the city neglecting the area, and interrupting municipal services such as garbage pickup for the people who didn't leave right away.

"The buildings that people moved out of were being left to rot rather than being cleared away and something new built," Clark said.

"We've lost a lot over the generations ... Obviously we would've stayed in the area."

WATCH | The past and future of Hogan's Alley: 

A look at the past and future of Hogan's Alley

2 years ago
Duration 1:07
Vancouver's Black neighbourhood was dismantled in the late 1960s to make room for the Georgia and Dunsmuir street viaducts.

A coast-to-coast connection

Over 50 years later, Carvery and Clark met for the first time next to the Georgia Viaduct and exchanged presents: Carvery gave Clark a t-shirt designed for the 25th anniversary reunion of residents of Africville, and a limited-edition poster of Africville jazz musician, Joe Sealy. 

Clark gave Carvery a picture of a current mural on the side of Nora Hendrix Place, a temporary modular housing project named after one of Hogan's Alley's most famous residents. The mural, depicting life in Hogan's Alley, was painted by Ejiwa "Edge" Ebenebe.

Two men exchange gifts in a grassy park in Vancouver.
Carvery and Clark exchange gifts to celebrate their historic meeting. (Gurpreet Kambo/CBC News)

But the meeting wasn't only about looking at the past. For both men, it was also about rebuilding. 

"I was very much interested in the work that the people in Hogan's Alley had done working with the City of Vancouver to reclaim their land back," said Carvery, adding he intends to apply similar strategies for the work in reclaiming Africville. 

Clark says it's also about seeing Hogan's Alley as a community with a future as much as a past.

"We're looking for partners," he said.

"As the community continues to develop, we want to be a part of that." 


For more stories about the experiences of Black Canadians — from anti-Black racism to success stories within the Black community — check out Being Black in Canada, a CBC project Black Canadians can be proud of. You can read more stories here.

A banner of upturned fists, with the words 'Being Black in Canada'.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Gurpreet Kambo is an Associate Producer for CBC Radio Vancouver. You can contact him at [email protected] or on Twitter at @gkam99

With files from The Early Edition