New Brunswick

FHS dress code protest penalties too harsh, parents say

The dress code controversy at Fredericton High School has provoked reaction from some frustrated parents who say the suspensions and extracurricular activity bans the student protesters are facing are too harsh.

About 15 students suspended for 3 to 5 days, banned from extracurricular activies for rest of year

N.B. Newsmaker Dec. 1: Shane Thomas

10 years ago
Duration 7:13
Fredericton High School principal Shane Thomas speaks about the dress code protest and penalties.

Some parents of Fredericton High School students say the principal is imposing overly harsh penalties on female students who took part in a recent protest against the dress code policy at the school.

About 15 students are facing class suspensions of between three and five days, starting on Tuesday. They have also been barred from all extracurricular activities for the remainder of the school year.

Jula Hughes was among the Fredericton High School parents who met with Anglophone West School District Superintendent David McTimoney on Monday about the dress code protest and punishment. (CBC)
A few of the parents met with the superintendent of  the Anglophone West School District on Monday to request a review.

"We argued that there should be an opportunity for parents and students and the administration at FHS to review what actually happened" before the suspensions are implemented, said parent Jula Hughes.

Gia Milani agrees. She says she gave her daughter Vivi Whalen, written permission to take part in the Nov. 21 protest led by the group Fredericton Youth Feminists and was shocked to learn Friday that she was facing suspension.

Gia Milani says she gave her daughter, Vivi Whalen, written permission to participate in the Nov. 21 protest at Fredericton High School. (CBC)
Vivi is an honours student with a 91 per cent average and has never even had detention before, said Milani, who decided to keep her home on Monday.

"I  just don't feel that the atmosphere at the school is conducive to a good work environment right now," she said.

Superintendent David McTimoney told CBC News suspensions are a principal's prerogative.

Principal Shane Thomas says he is willing to re-evaluate the length of the ban on extracurricular activities, such as prom, sports, junior achievement and various groups. But he says that won't happen until the end of the semester in January.

Thomas says the suspended students will have academic support available to them over the course of the suspension.

Students were not suspended for protesting, but rather for violating the "positive learning workplace" policy by moving the rally inside the school to the administrative office, said Thomas.

He says their actions upset staff and got too disruptive.

"To the point where we had four police officers involved inside the building. So, you know, it escalated to the point where safety was an issue," said Thomas.

The students contend the dress code in the Anglophone West School District unfairly targets female students and has led to female students being kicked out of class.

They also say the rules place the blame for sexual assault and harassment onto the victim.